ABSTRACT
Understanding human gene function is fundamental to understanding and treating diseases. Research using the model organism Drosophila melanogaster benefits from a wealth of molecular genetic resources and information useful for efficient in vivo experimentation. Moreover, Drosophila offers a balance as a relatively simple organism that nonetheless exhibits complex multicellular activities. Recent examples demonstrate the power and continued promise of Drosophila research to further our understanding of conserved gene functions.
Introduction
Following the completion of the Human Genome Project and the advances in sequencing technologies and bioinformatics, thousands of disease genes have been identified, paving the road to a revolution in medicine. Nevertheless, we face significant impediment to further progress: in the majority of cases, we do not understand how variants in a gene cause disease because the function of the gene itself is not well understood. Much of the knowledge we do have has come from fundamental studies and reflects an understanding of function at the cellular level. To learn more about human health and treat diseases, we must study complex biological activities in multicellular contexts. Drosophila provides an exemplary system in which to study gene functions in specific tissues and developmental stages, and under normal or perturbed conditions (Ugur et al., 2016). Here, we highlight recent examples that demonstrate how a convergence of technology and investigation can provide new insights into the mysteries of multicellular life. These examples show how years of tool development and experimentation in the fly are enabling unique and deep biological discoveries with translational implications. As Drosophila biologist Curt Stern noted in 1954: “Progress often proceeds best on the basis of past accomplishments. New questions may be asked on the basis of old experiments and sometimes answers are possible because of information already available” (Stern, 1954). Building on more than a century of accumulated knowledge – and taking advantage of established and emerging molecular genetic technologies – fly research is well positioned to remain a leading contributor to our understanding of how genes control complex biological activities.
Mitochondria quality control
Studies of the Drosophila female germline have led to many fundamental discoveries in stem cell biology, egg formation, interaction between germline and soma, and cues deposited maternally to control embryonic patterning. A study by Lieber et al. (2019) documented a fascinating mechanism in the female germline that prevents the accumulation of deleterious mitochondrial mutations. Mitochondria have a high mutation rate and low levels of recombination of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA). In both mammals and flies, a selection mechanism in the female germline prevents the accumulation of deleterious mutations (reviewed in Palozzi et al., 2018). Using wild-type mtDNA from Drosophila yakuba and mutant mtDNA from Drosophila melanogaster (Ma et al., 2014), Lieber et al. were able to visualize mtDNA selection in the Drosophila female germline using species-specific fluorescent in situ hybridization probes to distinguish wild-type and mutant mtDNA. Strikingly, the first step in this selection process is fragmentation of the mitochondria, leading to physical separation of mitochondrial genomes into smaller mitochondrial compartments. Fragmented mitochondria that contain mutant genomes are eliminated by mitophagy, resulting in an overall increase in wild-type mtDNA (Lieber et al., 2019). Further studies on the regulation of this fundamental mechanism are likely to provide important insights in diseases associated with mitochondrial dysfunction.
Sugar and water regulation by hunger and thirst
Understanding how neurons are wired and how signals move through neuronal circuits to control behavior are important areas of neurobiology to which Drosophila is making fundamental contributions. Key to the progress made in recent years are the thousands of Gal4 and split Gal4 (Brand and Perrimon, 1993; Dionne et al., 2018) lines available in which genes or other DNA-encoded reagents can be expressed in a manner that is genetically defined and consistent across individuals. For neuroscience research, these resources allow single neurons or groups of neurons to be activated using UAS-TrpA1 (Hamada et al., 2008) and allow for Ca2+ imaging using G-CaMP (a high-affinity Ca2+ probe containing a single GFP molecule) (Nakai et al., 2001). These tools have enabled the mapping of neuronal circuits that regulate specific behaviors, as exemplified by a study from Jourjine et al. (2016). Thirst and hunger are induced in response to a bodily state of dehydration or starvation, respectively, in order to regain homeostasis. How the internal state of an organism induces these behaviors has remained an open question. Jourjine et al. (2016) identified a Gal4 driver expressed in the nervous system that, when combined with UAS-TrpA1 to activate neurons, increased feeding. They then further refined the location of the relevant neurons using an intersectional approach in which they limited Gal4 activity using the Gal4 repressor Gal80 (Suster et al., 2004). Subsequently, the group used a complementary RNA interference (RNAi)-based approach to identify genes relevant to thirst and found that hunger and thirst converge on the same set of neurons, suggesting that these neurons integrate the information and ‘weigh competing needs’ of the fly (Jourjine et al., 2016).
Organ cross-talk and sex differences in physiology
Understanding sex differences in metabolism and physiology has become an area of increased interest. Studies in this area are relevant to human health, including potential differences between male and female disease susceptibility. Studies in Drosophila have led to a deep understanding of how sex chromosome number is interpreted to activate downstream pathways controlling morphological and behavioral differences between male and female flies. A recent study by Hudry et al. (2019) comparing gene expression in the guts of males and females revealed male-biased expression of enzymes involved in carbohydrate transport and utilization. Hudry et al. demonstrate that, surprisingly, this sex difference in gut gene expression is controlled by the adjacent male gonad, which produces the ligand Upd1. Upd1 activates JAK-STAT signaling in the enterocytes located in the adjacent intestinal subregion, upregulating the expression of sugar-metabolism-related genes and leading to cytosolic citrate production (Hudry et al., 2019). In this context, the role of citrate is twofold: citrate export promotes food consumption and is also transferred to adjacent testes to promote male gamete maturation. This striking inter-organ communication between testis and gut may have relevance for a spectrum of conditions in humans resulting from the abnormal arrangement of internal organs.
Inter-organ growth coordination
Another important question for multicellular organisms is how the relative proportions of organs, limbs and so on are coordinated during development, even when one of the structures is damaged. A study by Boulan et al. (2019) took advantage of the Drosophila wing imaginal disc, a well-studied epithelial tissue composed of cells that are ‘set aside’ early in development and destined to form the wing during metamorphosis. Disruption of a ribosomal gene in the wing disc had a non-autonomous effect on growth of the eye imaginal disc. The group found that this process is controlled by Dilp8 (Garelli et al., 2012; Colombani et al., 2012), which is secreted when growth is inhibited and affects growth in other tissues via inhibition of the insect hormone ecdysone. Boulan et al. were able to further identify two relevant upstream factors: the bZIP-type transcription factor Xrp1, which is required for Dilp8 expression in slow-growing tissues, and the ribosomal protein RpS12, which acts as a sensor of tissue growth (Boulan et al., 2019). The study contributes to an increasingly clear picture of how tissue growth is coordinated both autonomously and non-autonomously, under normal and perturbed conditions.
Modeling cancer
In many cases, modeling a disease can be accomplished through perturbation of single genes. In other cases, however, the most appropriate model would include multiple genetic perturbations. This seems particularly relevant for modeling cancer, as tumors are well documented to have multiple genetic changes. Bangi et al. (2019) reported the identification of a therapeutic strategy using a platform designed to model complex genetic changes identified by sequencing of an individual patient's tumor. Specifically, they used a combination of RNAi and ectopic expression to perturb nine different genes in a manner that parallels that identified in the tumor. The model was used to identify a treatment strategy that was then implemented clinically. The patient experienced a ‘progression-free’ period of 3 months and a partial response lasting 8 months. The treatment was not curative and the necessarily n=1 nature of such a personalized approach makes it difficult to draw general conclusions. Nevertheless, the fact that it was possible to develop and screen a Drosophila model that included perturbation of nine genes is impressive and offers some degree of hope for patients who suffer from complex cancers with poor prognosis.
Concluding remarks
The extensive information we have about Drosophila provides a strong foundation on which to build a more complete mechanistic understanding of complex activities and answer as-yet-unanswered questions, including those that can only be addressed in whole-animal systems. With this expanding knowledge, we can seek out new means for preventing, controlling and treating human diseases. Although here we focused on examples related to uncovering gene function, Drosophila studies are also contributing to additional disease-relevant areas, including diagnosis of genetic diseases (reviewed by Bellen et al., 2019) and drug discovery or repurposing (e.g. see Ali et al., 2018). Technologies such as CRISPR knockout screens in human cells, single-cell RNA sequencing, and culture of tissue-specific organoids have expanded the range of questions that can be directly addressed using human cells. However, the availability of these technologies does not supplant the usefulness of model organisms; genetic models such as Drosophila remain relevant. In the area of single-cell sequencing, for example, the Drosophila system can provide comparison datasets that add confidence in the identification of new cell types and states, their markers, differentiation factors, and so on, similar to the way that fly functional genomic studies provide important comparative data for analyses of human genetic datasets. It would be unproductive to get caught up in debating whether this or that model system or approach is the best. Efficient study of conserved gene functions requires the use of both simple models such as Drosophila and more complex human-cell-based models, just as it requires the application of more than one experimental approach. Given the strength of Drosophila as a research system, there can be no doubt that the path ahead will continue to be informative and exciting.
Acknowledgements
The authors thank Drs Justin Bosch, Ben Ewen-Campen, Lucy Liu, Pedro Saavedra and Sudhir Tattikota for helpful comments on the manuscript.
Footnotes
Funding
Relevant support includes NIH National Institute of General Medical Sciences (NIGMS) R01GM067761 and Office of Research Infrastructure Programs (ORIP) R24OD021997. In addition, S.E.M. is supported in part by NIH National Cancer Institute (NCI) P30CA06516 and N.P. is an investigator at the Howard Hughes Medical Institute.
- © 2019. Published by The Company of Biologists Ltd
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution and reproduction in any medium provided that the original work is properly attributed.
References
Article navigation
Related articles
Cited by...
More in this TOC section
Similar articles
Subject collections
Other journals from The Company of Biologists
DMM and COVID-19
We are aware that the COVID-19 pandemic is having an unprecedented impact on researchers worldwide. The Editors of all The Company of Biologists’ journals have been considering ways in which we can alleviate concerns that members of our community may have around publishing activities during this time. Read about the actions we are taking at this time.
Please don’t hesitate to contact the Editorial Office if you have any questions or concerns.
A Model for Life – Elizabeth McNally and Louis Kunkel
Human geneticist and cardiologist Elizabeth McNally discusses her first experiences in science and the effort we all need to make to facilitate diversity in science, while Louis Kunkel tells us about talks about his discovery of dystrophin.
On the cover of our special issue, Demonbreun et al. present muscle fiber typing from a newly created mouse model of limb-girdle muscular dystrophy generated by gene editing.
Non-canonical autophagy in innate immune defence in vivo
preLighter Kirsty Hooper, The Babraham Institute, Cambridge, UK, discusses a preprint showing that loss of non-canonical autophagy in mice increases sensitivity to influenza A virus infection.
The Biology Open transfer option
DMM authors can transfer their submission to our sister journal Biology Open with just one click. An online Open Access journal, BiO also welcomes direct submissions and focuses on the swift publication of high-quality, sound research. Recent disease modelling highlights in BiO include work by Liu et al. investigating transgenic replenishment strategies targeting myocardial and non-myocardial tissues in the zebrafish. Find out more about how to transfer.
Editor’s choice
Highlighted by the Guest editors of our special issue, Grunwald and colleagues use zebrafish to investigate interactions among ryanodine receptor isotypes in muscle development and function, while Claire Wood et al. tests the mdx:Cmah−/− mouse to investigate growth and skeletal development in Duchenne muscular dystrophy.