Mutations in the human NOTCH3 gene cause CADASIL syndrome (cerebral autosomal dominant arteriopathy with subcortical infarcts and leukoencephalopathy). CADASIL is an inherited small vessel disease characterized by diverse clinical manifestations including vasculopathy, neurodegeneration and dementia. Here we report two mutations in the zebrafish notch3 gene, one identified in a previous screen for mutations with reduced expression of myelin basic protein (mbp) and another caused by a retroviral insertion. Reduced mbp expression in notch3 mutant embryos is associated with fewer oligodendrocyte precursor cells (OPCs). Despite an early neurogenic phenotype, mbp expression recovered at later developmental stages and some notch3 homozygous mutants survived to adulthood. These mutants, as well as adult zebrafish carrying both mutant alleles together, displayed a striking stress-associated accumulation of blood in the head and fins. Histological analysis of mutant vessels revealed vasculopathy, including: an enlargement (dilation) of vessels in the telencephalon and fin, disorganization of the normal stereotyped arrangement of vessels in the fin, and an apparent loss of arterial morphological structure. Expression of hey1, a well-known transcriptional target of Notch signaling, was greatly reduced in notch3 mutant fins, suggesting that Notch3 acts via a canonical Notch signaling pathway to promote normal vessel structure. Ultrastructural analysis confirmed the presence of dilated vessels in notch3 mutant fins and revealed that the vessel walls of presumed arteries showed signs of deterioration. Gaps in the arterial wall and the presence of blood cells outside of vessels in mutants indicated that compromised vessel structure led to hemorrhage. In notch3 heterozygotes, we found elevated expression of both notch3 itself and target genes, indicating that specific alterations in gene expression due to partial loss of Notch3 function might contribute to the abnormalities observed in heterozygous larvae and adults. Our analysis of zebrafish notch3 mutants indicates that Notch3 regulates OPC development and mbp gene expression in larvae, and maintains vascular integrity in adults.
The Notch signaling pathway is widely conserved among metazoans. Vertebrate genomes contain several Notch paralogs, which control key developmental decisions at numerous stages and in diverse tissues and organs (Andersson et al., 2011; Gazave et al., 2009). The Notch pathway is ideally suited for signaling between adjacent cells because both the Notch receptor and its ligands are transmembrane proteins (Kopan and Ilagan, 2009). This feature allows Notch signals to assign different fates to adjacent cells with similar developmental potential. According to prevailing models, feedback mechanisms amplify small differences in the expression levels of Notch receptor and ligand in neighboring cells, resulting in active Notch signaling in one cell and suppression of Notch signaling in the other. This lateral inhibition mechanism directs binary fate decisions in many species and developmental contexts, including neurogenesis in Drosophila (Ruohola et al., 1991), development of the inner ear and the intestine in vertebrates (Cotanche and Kaiser, 2010; Crosnier et al., 2005; Haddon et al., 1998a; Heath, 2010), and development of the vertebrate vasculature (Gridley, 2010). In the developing vasculature, Notch signaling inhibits endothelial cells from adopting a tip cell fate during sprouting angiogenesis (Sainson et al., 2005). Accordingly, inhibition of Notch signaling in zebrafish and mouse leads to increased sprouting and branching of vessels due to supernumerary tip cells (Leslie et al., 2007; Siekmann and Lawson, 2007). The Notch pathway also confers arterial identity to endothelial cells and vascular mural cells [e.g. vascular smooth muscle cells (VSMCs) and pericytes] (Domenga et al., 2004; Lawson et al., 2001).
In Drosophila, notch pathway mutants have neurogenic phenotypes characterized by an excess of neuronal cells (Campos-Ortega, 1985). The role of Notch signaling in limiting neurogenesis is conserved in vertebrates (Lewis, 1996). Mutants disrupting vertebrate pathway components also display neurogenic phenotypes (Imayoshi et al., 2010; Yoon et al., 2008). These phenotypes have been attributed to excessive differentiation of neural progenitor cells (NPCs) into neurons, which depletes the progenitor pool in notch pathway mutants. Thus, Notch regulates the balance between neuronal differentiation and maintenance of progenitor cell fates, including of radial glia. Notch also drives differentiation of other glial cell types (e.g. Müller glia of the retina), and Notch activity is thought to broadly control the balance between neurogenesis and gliogenesis (Pierfelice et al., 2011). In addition, Notch activity promotes expansion of oligodendrocyte precursor cells (OPCs), while inhibiting their terminal differentiation (Park and Appel, 2003; Wang et al., 1998). Outside of the nervous system, the Notch pathway contributes to the maintenance of other progenitor and stem cell populations, such as Leydig progenitor cells of the testis and melanocyte stem cells (Moriyama et al., 2006; Tang et al., 2008).
Mutations in the human NOTCH3 gene cause cerebral autosomal dominant arteriopathy with subcortical infarcts and leukoencephalopathy (CADASIL). CADASIL is an inherited disease characterized by progressive degeneration of small blood vessels, which leads to a diverse set of clinical manifestations including vasculopathy, neurodegeneration and dementia. None of the existing CADASIL mouse models fully recapitulates the human disease. In light of the variability among patients and the limitations of currently available NOTCH3 and CADASIL animal models, the mechanism by which NOTCH3 mutations cause CADASIL symptoms – including vascular, white matter and other disease phenotypes – remain to be clarified.
In this study, zebrafish notch3 mutants were analyzed to gain insight into the mechanisms underlying CADASIL pathophysiology. The authors report that mutations in notch3 reduce the expression of myelin basic protein (mbp) and the number of oligodendrocyte precursor cells (OPCs). Despite displaying an early neurogenic phenotype, some notch3 homozygous mutants survived to adulthood. These mutants, as well as adult zebrafish carrying both mutant alleles together, displayed a striking stress-associated accumulation of blood in the head and fins. The authors’ histological analysis revealed vasculopathy in the mutants, including enlarged vessels in the brain and peripheral circulatory system and an apparent loss of arterial morphological structure. Moreover, ultrastructural analysis revealed signs of vessel deterioration in notch3 mutants, including gaps in the arterial wall and the presence of blood cells outside of vessels. Subsequent examination of Notch pathway target genes indicated that Notch3 acts via a canonical Notch signaling pathway to promote normal vessel structure. In notch3 heterozygotes, expression of notch3 and its target genes was elevated, indicating that alterations in gene expression occur in response to partial loss of Notch3.
Implications and future directions
These analyses of zebrafish notch3 mutants indicate that Notch3 regulates OPC development and mbp gene expression in larvae, and plays a conserved role in maintaining vascular tone and vessel integrity in adults. Changes in gene expression and cell death in the CNS were observed specifically in notch3 heterozygotes, suggesting that a partial loss of Notch3 function could contribute to aspects of the pathophysiology of CADASIL. These changes were not detected using previously reported animal models that completely lack Notch3 expression. Zebrafish notch3 mutants provide a valuable tool for future screens aiming to identify Notch signaling modifiers that affect the phenotype, and for studies of the activity of CADASIL mutant alleles and the signaling and cellular mechanisms that contribute to Notch3-associated pathologies.
Mutations in the human NOTCH3 gene cause CADASIL syndrome (cerebral autosomal dominant arteriopathy with subcortical infarcts and leukoencephalopathy). CADASIL is a small vessel disease that has been diagnosed in more than 500 families worldwide (Hervé and Chabriat, 2010). Clinical symptoms comprise migraine with aura, leukoaraiosis, subcortical infarcts, mood disturbances, apathy and dementia (Hervé and Chabriat, 2010). Many pathological mutations in CADASIL result in an odd number of cysteines in one of the EGF repeats of NOTCH3, which is thought to cause aggregation of the NOTCH3 extracellular domain (NECD) in individuals with CADASIL (Joutel et al., 1997; Opherk et al., 2009). The majority of individuals with CADASIL display leukoaraiosis and ischemic events that are particularly prominent in the white matter of the CNS, a region characterized by low blood flow that consists primarily of glial cells and myelinated axons (Lee et al., 2012). In the CNS, oligodendrocytes form myelin, a multi-lamellar sheath that allows for rapid impulse propagation by saltatory conduction in the vertebrate nervous system. Damage to oligodendrocytes and demyelination of axons can cause or contribute to neurodegenerative pathology, as occurs in the CNS in multiple sclerosis (MS) (Prineas and Parratt, 2012). The demyelination of axons might contribute to the cerebral atrophy seen in individuals with CADASIL (Viswanathan et al., 2006); however, axonal damage and atrophy in the white matter has also been viewed as a secondary defect to vascular disruption.
Histopathological analysis revealed that CADASIL is a vasculopathy of small cerebral and systemic arteries (Baudrimont et al., 1993; Ruchoux et al., 1995). In CADASIL, the VSMCs show signs of degeneration and eventually are lost. Endothelial dysfunction and ultrastructural endothelial changes also have been reported in CADASIL. Although vascular changes are observed all along the arterial tree, and in liver, muscle, spleen and skin, organ failure is only apparent in the brain and retina (Robinson et al., 2001; Ruchoux et al., 1995). It is not clear why widespread arteriopathy does not cause more global organ defects.
In an effort to better understand CADASIL pathologies, Notch3 knockout, knock-in and transgenic mouse models have been developed (Arboleda-Velasquez et al., 2011; Arboleda-Velasquez et al., 2005; Joutel, 2011; Joutel et al., 2004; Krebs et al., 2003; Monet-Leprêtre et al., 2009; Ruchoux et al., 2003). The defective constrictive responses upon experimental challenge by proximal middle cerebral artery occlusion and the enlarged arteries with thinner walls that are observed in Notch3 knockout mice indicate roles for Notch3 in arterial VSMC specification and maturation in tail vessels, and in maintaining vascular tone (Arboleda-Velasquez et al., 2008; Belin de Chantemèle et al., 2008; Domenga et al., 2004; Krebs et al., 2003). Although arteriopathies in the tail and, when challenged, cortical vessels (Arboleda-Velasquez et al., 2008) have been observed in knockout mice, important pathologies and hallmarks of CADASIL – including Notch3 ectodomain deposits, leukoencephalopathy and lacunar infarcts – have not been found. Nevertheless, Notch3 knockout mice show a higher susceptibility for ischemic stroke (Arboleda-Velasquez et al., 2008). None of the existing CADASIL mice fully recapitulates the human disease. In light of this variability among the available Notch3 and CADASIL animal models, the mechanism by which Notch3 mutations cause CADASIL symptoms is not known, and the mechanism and extent of interdependence of the vascular, white matter and other disease phenotypes remain to be clarified.
In a genetic screen to identify genes that are required for the development of myelinated axons in zebrafish, st51 was discovered as a mutation that reduced myelin basic protein (mbp) mRNA expression in the CNS (Pogoda et al., 2006). Here we show that st51 disrupts the zebrafish notch3 gene. Analysis of notch3st51 and an insertional allele of notch3 revealed that notch3 is required for OPC development and myelin gene expression during larval development. At later stages, mbp expression increased in the CNS of notch3 mutants, and some homozygous mutants survived to adulthood. In these adult mutants, we observed bleeding in response to mild stress. Histological and electron microscopy (EM) analyses revealed enlarged vessels in the telencephalon and fins, which indicated that blood accumulation was due to dilation and leaking of the vessels in notch3 mutant adults. Our studies of zebrafish notch3 mutants provide evidence that Notch3 plays a conserved role in maintaining vascular tone and vessel integrity in vertebrate adult vessels. The presence of oligodendrocyte abnormalities before vascular pathology provides evidence that notch3 might function in parallel in myelination and vasculogenesis.
Identification of mutations in notch3
In a screen for zebrafish mutants with abnormal myelination, Pogoda et al. identified st51 as a mutation that reduced mbp expression in the CNS at 5 dpf (Pogoda et al., 2006). Previous mapping experiments localized the st51 mutation to linkage group 3 (Pogoda et al., 2006). To identify the gene disrupted by st51, we conducted additional mapping experiments and localized the mutation to an interval bordered by the simple sequence length polymorphism (SSLP) markers Z3725 and Z20058, which contains the notch3 gene (Woods et al., 2005). Sequence analysis of genomic DNA from st51 mutants revealed a G-to-A transition in the mutant allele that disrupts the splice donor site after exon 13 in the notch3 gene (Fig. 1A). We detected no recombination between this lesion and the st51 mutation among 348 meioses (data not shown), indicating that st51 was tightly linked to notch3. Reverse transcriptase PCR (RT-PCR) analysis of RNA isolated from wild-type and mutant larvae at 3 dpf revealed that the notch3 pre-mRNA was aberrantly spliced in st51 homozygotes, such that intron 13was retained in the majority of mutant transcripts (Fig. 1B,C). Retention of this intron in the predominant mutant transcript caused truncation of the predicted notch3 open reading frame in the extracellular region, after the 17th EGF repeat (Fig. 1B). In addition, a minority of the mutant notch3 mRNAs contained aberrantly spliced sequences that result in partial deletions of exon 13. Sequence analysis identified two such deletions, a 15 bp deletion that maintained the reading frame, and a 103 bp deletion that induced a frameshift, truncating the predicted notch3 reading frame after the 16th EGF repeat (Fig. 1B,C).
To further investigate the function of notch3, we obtained and examined a commercially available notch3 allele, ZM_197263, produced by insertional mutagenesis. The ZM_197263 mutation (referred to as ‘zm’ hereafter) contains a retroviral insertion in the 5′UTR of the notch3 gene, 158 nucleotides upstream of the open reading frame (Fig. 1A). In wild-type animals, notch3 was expressed throughout the nervous system, including in the hindbrain (Fig. 1D). Compared with wild type (Fig. 1D,G; n=5 each), notch3st51/+ and notch3zm/+ heterozygous siblings (Fig. 1E,H; n=11 each) and notch3st51/st51 mutants (Fig. 1F; n=7) showed enhanced expression of notch3 in the CNS, a finding we return to below. In contrast, little if any notch3 mRNA was detectable in notch3zm/zm mutants (Fig. 1I; n=9), indicating that notch3zm is a strong loss-of-function mutation.
To examine the phenotype of notch3zm/zm mutants and determine whether st51 and zm fail to complement, we examined mbp expression in early larvae (Fig. 1J–Q). Expression of mbp was similar to wild type in notch3st51/+ heterozygotes (Fig. 1K), but was reduced in the CNS of notch3st51/st51 homozygotes (Fig. 1L) and notch3zm/zm homozygotes (Fig. 1M). The reduction of mbp expression in the CNS of notch3zm/zm mutants, notch3st51/st51 homozygotes and notch3st51/zm transheterozygotes at 5 dpf (Fig. 1N–Q and data not shown) indicated that the st51 and zm mutations failed to complement. Moreover, the reduction seemed to be more severe in notch3zm/zm mutants, suggesting that the notch3st51 mutation might have more residual notch3 function than does notch3zm. On the basis of mapping data, the identification of lesions that disrupt the splicing or expression level of notch3 and complementation analysis, we conclude that both the st51 and zm mutations disrupt the function of notch3. Phenotypic and molecular studies suggest that notch3zm is a null or near-null mutation, and that notch3st51 is a hypomorphic allele that probably retains weak notch3 function. The residual Notch3 activity in notch3st51/st51 homozygotes is probably provided by the minor splice variant with the 15 bp deletion that maintains the reading frame in these mutants. These results demonstrate that notch3 is essential for normal expression of mbp in the larval CNS.
Transient reduction in OPCs in notch3 mutant larvae
Mutational analysis shows that notch3 is essential for normal expression of mbp mRNA in the CNS of zebrafish larvae (Pogoda et al., 2006) (and this work). To investigate the possibility that an early deficit in oligodendrocytes underlies reduced mbp expression in notch3 mutants, we examined oligodendrocyte transcription factor 2 (olig2), which is expressed in OPCs and motor neurons (Park et al., 2002; Park et al., 2007; Shin et al., 2003; Takebayashi et al., 2000; Zannino and Appel, 2009). At 24 hpf, expression of olig2 was comparable between wild type, notch3st51/+ heterozygotes and notch3st51/st51 homozygotes (data not shown). However, olig2 expression was reduced in OPCs of notch3st51/st51 mutants at 50 hpf (Fig. 2C,C′; n=5) compared with wild type (Fig. 2A,A′; n=2) and notch3st51/+ heterozygotes (Fig. 2B,B′; n=8). At 52 hpf, expression of sox10, an independent marker of cells of the oligodendrocyte lineage, was also reduced in the midline of the hindbrain in notch3st51/st51 mutants (Fig. 2F, compared with 2D,E). These results suggested that a partial loss of OPCs resulted in the reduced expression of mbp in the CNS of notch3 mutants. This analysis indicates that notch3 is required for OPC development and myelin gene expression in the embryo and early larva. Despite these defects at earlier stages, some notch3 mutants achieve normal levels of mbp expression in the hindbrain by 7 dpf (data not shown).
In individuals with CADASIL, loss of myelin accompanies and has been proposed to be caused by vascular defects (Okeda et al., 2002), and adult notch3 knockout mice have vascular defects. Although swim bladder inflation was delayed at 5 days post-fertilization (dpf), no overt evidence of edema or compromised circulation was detected morphologically at 3–5 dpf (stages when OPC defects were apparent among progeny) in notch3st51/st51 or notch3zm/zm mutants from five independent heterozygous incrosses. To more closely examine vessel patterning, we conducted microangiography and crossed the notch3 mutations into the Tg[fli1a:EGFP] background (Lawson and Weinstein, 2002b). As compared with wild-type genotypes, microangiography (supplementary material Fig. S1A–C) and expression of Tg[fli1a:EGFP] (Fig. 2G–I and supplementary material Fig. S2) indicated that, at the anatomical level, overall sprouting, vessel branching and morphogenesis were intact in notch3 mutants at stages before and after OPC deficits were already apparent. Consistent with Tg[fli1a:EGFP] analysis and microangiography, vascular markers [deltaC (dlC), ephrinB2 (efn2ba/ephB2), fms-related tyrosine kinase 4 (flt4) and disabled homolog 2 (dab2)] were indistinguishable between wild type, notch3zm/+ heterozygotes and notch3zm/zm mutants at 28 hpf (supplementary material Fig. S3A–L), providing additional evidence that, at the anatomical level, arterial venous identity and arterial venous patterning of the vasculature is intact at stages when OPCs and oligodendrocytes are disrupted in notch3 mutants.
Neurogenic phenotype of notch3 mutants and apoptosis in notch3 heterozygotes
To investigate whether the reduction of OPCs in notch3 mutants was due to loss of progenitors via cell death, we used Acridine Orange (AO) to label cells undergoing apoptosis. At 52 hpf, AO staining was similar in the CNS of wild-type siblings (Fig. 3A; n=12) and notch3st51/st51 mutants (Fig. 3C; n=8), indicating that the reduction of OPCs in notch3 mutants was not due to cell death. Because apoptosis did not account for reduced OPCs in mutants, we examined the expression of progenitor and differentiation markers. During neuronal development, deltaD expression in precursors prevents neighboring notch-expressing cells from adopting neuronal fates (Haddon et al., 1998b; Hans and Campos-Ortega, 2002; Mahler et al., 2010; Takke et al., 1999). We observed abundant deltaD mRNA (Fig. 3D–I) in lateral regions of notch3st51/st51 (Fig. 3F; n=11) and notch3zm/zm (Fig. 3I; n=2 at 48 hpf and 4 at 54 hpf) mutants, with holes in deltaD expression in medial regions similar to the gaps in notch3 and notch1a expression that were present in notch3st51/st51 mutants (Fig. 1F; n=11 and supplementary material Fig. S4). To further investigate the development of neural progenitors, we examined gfap expression at 52 hpf, which marks radial glial progenitors at this stage (Fig. 3J–L). As we observed for notch3 and deltaD, there were medial gaps in gfap expression in notch3 mutants (Fig. 3L; st51: n=8; zm: n=9), indicating that OPCs might be reduced owing to aberrant differentiation of medial progenitors.
To investigate the possibility that the reduction of OPCs results from a neurogenic phenotype in notch3 mutants, we examined HuC/D, which marks post-mitotic neurons. In contrast to wild type (Fig. 3M) and notch3 heterozygotes (Fig. 3N and data not shown), notch3 mutants had abundant HuC/D expression (Fig. 3O and data not shown) and acetylated tubulin staining (compare with Fig. 3P–R) in medial regions of R3/R5, consistent with the possibility that OPCs are reduced because progenitors are inappropriately allocated to neuronal fates in notch3 mutants. In other regions of the embryo, major axonal projections were comparable between wild type and notch3 mutants (supplementary material Fig. S5).
A striking feature of the foregoing analysis is that notch3 heterozygotes expressed highly elevated levels of Notch pathway components, including deltaD [Fig. 3E (80% of notch3st51/+ heterozygotes; n=26); Fig. 3H (n=9 notch3zm/+ heterozygotes at 48 hpf and 6 notch3zm/+ heterozygotes at 54 hpf)] and notch3 itself (Fig. 1E), and the progenitor marker gfap (Fig. 3K). In addition, AO staining revealed elevated cell death in the CNS of notch3st51/+ (Fig. 3B; n=12) and notch3zm/+ (n=2) heterozygotes that was not seen in wild type or homozygous mutants (Fig. 3A, n=12; Fig. 3C, n=8). Despite these changes in gene expression and cell death, notch3 heterozygotes were fully viable and fertile. Indeed, even some notch3 homozygous mutants achieved normal levels of mbp expression in the hindbrain by 7 dpf (data not shown) and survived to adulthood.
Compromised vascular tone in notch3 mutant adults
Despite the reduced numbers of OPCs in notch3st51/st51 and notch3zm/zm mutants, a subset of the mutants recovered from these early zygotic phenotypes and survived to adulthood. Homozygous notch3st51/st51 and notch3zm/zm males that survived to adulthood were fertile. However, in response to mild stress (such as moving the tank from the rack, or mating), the homozygous mutant adults displayed an accumulation of blood within the head and fins that was not observed in wild-type or heterozygous siblings (Fig. 4). In notch3zm/+ (Fig. 4A,E) and notch3st51/+ (Fig. 4C,E) heterozygous siblings, blood was evident at the base of the fins, but did not extend into the caudal fin rays. In contrast, blood extended from the base to the tip of the fins in notch3zm/zm (Fig. 4B,E) and notch3st51/st51 (Fig. 4D,E) homozygotes and notch3st51/zm transheterozygotes (data not shown), indicating that vascular tone might be compromised in notch3 mutant adults. As observed for the reduction in mbp expression in the larvae, notch3zm/zm mutants showed more pronounced phenotypes compared with notch3st51/st51 mutants.
CADASIL is a vasculopathy of small cerebral and systemic arteries caused by mutations in NOTCH3 (Baudrimont et al., 1993; Ruchoux et al., 1995). We conducted histopathological analysis to investigate whether adult zebrafish notch3 mutants showed any evidence of vasculopathy in the brain. Compared with wild-type (Fig. 5A,B,G) and heterozygous (Fig. 5C,D,I) genotypes, vessels were more prominent in the telencephalon of notch3zm/zm (Fig. 5E,H) and notch3st51/st51 mutants (Fig. 5F,J). In contrast, the tectum of wild-type zebrafish had highly branched large- and small-diameter vessels (Fig. 5A), whereas the tectum of notch3 mutants was covered with small-diameter vessels and capillaries (Fig. 5E,F). Histological analysis of hematoxylin and eosin (H&E)-stained sections within the medial telencephalon confirmed the presence of small vessels (probably capillaries) traversing the tissue of notch3zm/+ and notch3st51/+ heterozygotes (Fig. 5K,M). In contrast, abnormally large vessels were present in notch3zm/zm and notch3st51/st51 mutant telencephalon (Fig. 5L,N), indicative of vasculopathy in notch3 mutant brain tissue.
Defective organization and vasodilation of vessels in notch3 mutants
To further investigate the basis for the accumulation of blood in notch3 mutants, we conducted histological analysis of caudal fin tissue isolated from notch3 mutants. Wild-type fins had the expected highly ordered reiterative structure of dermal, vascular and nervous tissues, with veins occupying the joints between and arteries within bony regions (Fig. 6A,B; n=2). This ordered pattern was largely intact in notch3zm/+ and notch3st51/+ heterozygotes (Fig. 6C,E; n=2 each). By contrast, in notch3st51/st51 mutants (Fig. 6D; n=2) veins were not limited to the joints and extended into the bony regions, which were co-occupied by multiple distended vessels. Similar but more severe phenotypes were observed in notch3zm/zm mutants (Fig. 6F; n=2). Even with higher magnification, it was difficult to unambiguously identify arteries in the notch3zm/zm mutant fins (Fig. 6F).
In order to quantitatively assess the vessel defects given the difficulty in distinguishing arteries from veins in notch mutants, we determined the ratio of the vessel diameter within the bony segments of the fin ray, where arteries are typically located, to the distance between the bones (Fig. 6G). This ratio was not significantly different between wild-type and notch3st51/+ or notch3zm/+ heterozygotes (Fig. 6H). In contrast, notchst51/st51 and notch3zm/zm mutants showed statistically significant distension of the vessels residing within bony regions of the fin ray, such that vessels in notch3zm/zm mutants showed a threefold increase in relative diameter.
Consistent with the vascular phenotypes of notch3 mutants, notch3 expression was prominent in arteries of adult fin (Fig. 7A). In notch3 mutants, the vessels within bony regions, where arteries normally reside, showed morphological features that were more reminiscent of veins. To investigate whether the notch3 mutant vessels within bony segments showed aberrant morphology because they had lost their arterial identity, we examined the expression of deltaC, a marker of arterial identity. As in notch3zm/+ heterozygotes (Fig. 7B), notch3zm/zm mutants (Fig. 7C) expressed deltaC in the enlarged vessels within bony segments. Importantly, deltaC was not expressed in the vessels that run adjacent to the bony segments, indicating that those vessels kept their venous identity. We also examined flt4, which was expressed in arteries and veins within the fin of notch3zm/+ heterozygotes (Fig. 7D) and notch3zm/zm mutants (Fig. 7E). These analyses indicate that, although the mutant arteries displayed morphological features of veins, their arterial identity was intact in notch3zm/zm mutants.
Previous studies of mouse Notch3 knockout mice suggest distinct mechanisms by which Notch3 functions. One proposed mechanism involves the regulation of canonical Notch targets such as Hey and Hes genes (Arboleda-Velasquez et al., 2008), whereas the second points to a newly identified pathway whereby Notch3 activates unknown targets (Domenga et al., 2004). Moreover, human CADASIL mutations show a differing ability to bind Jagged1 ligand and to activate canonical Notch targets (e.g. RBP-Jκ) (Joutel et al., 2004). To investigate the pathway underlying compromised vascular tone in zebrafish notch3 mutants, we surveyed the expression of canonical Notch targets in mutant fins (Fig. 7F,G). We found that the canonical notch target hey1 was significantly reduced in notch3zm/zm and notch3st51/st51 mutant fins (Fig. 7F), and that levels of her9 were not significantly changed (Fig. 7G). These results indicate that Notch3 acts via a mechanism that involves the activation of canonical Notch targets to promote vascular tone and integrity.
Compromised vessel integrity leads to hemorrhage of vessels in notch3 mutants
To investigate whether the accumulation of blood in the fins of notch3 mutants was due to compromised vascular tone or reflected a more severe defect (hemorrhaging of the vessels), we used EM to examine the vascular ultrastructure. In wild type (Fig. 7H,I) and notch3zm/+ heterozygotes (Fig. 7J,K), arteries and veins were readily distinguishable, albeit that veins seemed to be larger in notch3zm/+ heterozygotes, suggesting a mild defect in vascular tone. In notch3zm/zm mutants the vessels were severely dilated and arteries were difficult to distinguish from veins (Fig. 7L,M and data not shown). Mural cells associated with vessels were easily identifiable in wild-type and heterozygous genotypes, but could not be unambiguously identified in notch3 mutants. Moreover, gaps in the vessel walls and the presence of blood cells outside of the vessels indicated that the pooling of blood in the fins of notch3zm/zm mutants was probably due to both loss of vascular tone and hemorrhage of the notch3 mutant vessels (compare Fig. 7N and 7O).
The Notch pathway is highly conserved and is widely used to mediate cell fate decisions in embryonic and adult tissues (reviewed in Kopan and Ilagan, 2009). Mutations disrupting human NOTCH3 cause CADASIL, an inherited small vessel disease associated with neurodegeneration and cognitive decline with advanced patient age (Hervé and Chabriat, 2010). Prevailing models indicate that cognitive decline might be secondary to vascular pathology, but this remains an open question because the existing mouse knockins of common patient NOTCH3 alleles recapitulate some but not all of the CADASIL pathologies. The two reported Notch3 knockout mouse models are susceptible to stroke when challenged, but no other neural deficits have been reported. Studies of these knockout mouse mutants point to opposing models of Notch3 function in establishing vascular structure. Based on their analysis of one knockout mutation, Domenga et al. presented evidence for a vascular defect and argue for a non-canonical mechanism (Domenga et al., 2004), whereas Arboleda-Velasquez et al. did not report vascular structure defects in a different knockout strain and argued that a canonical pathway was important for the regulation of gene expression in vascular smooth muscle cells (VSMCs) (Arboleda-Velasquez et al., 2011; Arboleda-Velasquez et al., 2008). Although the mouse analyses present different views of the role of notch3 in establishing vascular structure, our analysis of zebrafish notch3 mutants provides strong evidence that notch3 has a conserved function in sustaining mature vessel structure and maintaining vascular integrity, probably via a canonical pathway, as indicated by reduced hey1 in notch3 mutants. In addition, our studies of zebrafish notch3 mutants provide evidence that notch3 regulates OPC development and mbp gene expression in larvae and promotes mural cell and artery maturation in adults. Our analysis of neural development reveal that notch3 mutant larvae have a neurogenic phenotype and that notch3 heterozygous larvae have abnormalities in development of the CNS that are not seen in homozygous mutants.
We demonstrate that notch3 is essential for normal differentiation of neural progenitors during embryogenesis. In the developing hindbrain of notch3 mutants, there were prominent gaps in the expression of neural progenitor markers, and excess neurons developed at the expense of OPCs. When Notch signaling is disrupted, excess neurons often differentiate at early stages at the expense of later-born cell types, including OPCs (Bingham et al., 2003; Haddon et al., 1998a; Itoh et al., 2003; Park et al., 2000; Shih and Keller, 1992). In the zebrafish embryo, Qiu et al. reported that Notch3 and Notch1a have redundant functions in controlling hindbrain patterning and neurogenesis (Qiu et al., 2009). They found that excess neurons developed in notch1a mutants that also had reduced notch3 function (via morpholino injection), and rhombomere boundaries were not maintained. In combination, our analysis and the results of Qiu et al. suggest that notch3 mutants have reduced OPCs in the early larval stage because of misallocation of the fates of some early neural progenitors (Qiu et al., 2009). Furthermore, the relatively mild and transient notch3 mutant phenotype might reflect redundancy with notch1a. It is possible that, in the mouse, Notch3 has a similar role in OPC development that is masked by overlapping functions of other notch genes.
The elevated expression of notch3, deltaD and gfap and increased apoptosis in the CNS of notch3 heterozygotes was a striking finding of our analysis. The elevation of progenitor markers suggests that the differentiation of some progenitors might be delayed by the partial reduction of Notch signaling in notch3 heterozygotes. The elevated cell death in the heterozygotes suggests that some of these delayed progenitors undergo apoptosis, but the majority must differentiate properly because the pattern of neurons and OPCs is apparently normal and the fish are fully viable. The finding of changes in gene expression and cell death in the CNS specific to notch3 heterozygotes suggests that a partial loss of Notch3 function could contribute to aspects of the pathophysiology of CADASIL that have not been observed in animals that completely lack notch3 function.
Based largely on the temporal manifestation and detection of phenotypes, leukoaraiosis, subcortical ischemic events, mood disturbances, apathy and dementia have been thought to be secondary to vascular defects and reduced capillary density (reviewed in Hervé and Chabriat, 2010; Kalimo et al., 2002; Pantoni, 2010). Analysis of zebrafish cloche mutants, which lack endothelium but have normal hindbrain neuron clusters and axon tracts, provides evidence that endothelium is not required for proper patterning and organization of neurons in the early hindbrain (Ulrich et al., 2011). In zebrafish notch3 mutants, OPCs are already reduced at stages when gross vascular patterning is intact, as assessed by the Tg[fli1a:EGFP] transgene, microangiography and endothelial markers. In addition, the OPC deficits are evident at stages when the other cell type of the vessel, the mural cell, has not been specified or undergone maturation (Miano et al., 2006; Santoro et al., 2009). Taken together, this indicates that notch3 is likely to have parallel roles in regulating OPC development and mbp gene expression in larvae, and in promoting vascular integrity. Future investigation is required to identify the notch3 targets involved in the abnormalities in OPC development and vasculopathy in brain and peripheral tissues, and to determine whether the brain phenotypes involve communication between neural and vascular cells, which has been proposed to account for the non-autonomous neuropathology in CADASIL phenotypes. Alternatively, in mouse and zebrafish, notch3 is expressed widely in neural progenitors (Irvin et al., 2001; Lindsell et al., 1996; Qiu et al., 2009); therefore, the effects might instead be later manifestations of a notch3 function in neural development rather than a secondary consequence of vascular defects.
Some zebrafish notch3 mutants survive to adulthood. This is probably due to compensation by other notch family members such as notch1a, because adult mutants that are homozygous even for the presumed null notch3zm allele were recovered. Those notch3 mutants that do survive show enlarged vessels in the telencephalon and accumulation of blood in peripheral vessels along the rostral caudal axis (in particular within the pectoral, anal and caudal fins), indicating loss of vascular tone within peripheral vessels. Cardiovascular development in zebrafish, as in mammals, involves specification of endothelial cell fates during the earliest stages of vessel development. Arterial differentiation is regulated by Shh, vascular endothelial growth factor (Vegf) and Notch signaling in zebrafish and in other vertebrates (Lawson et al., 2001; Lawson et al., 2002; Lawson and Weinstein, 2002a; Torres-Vázquez et al., 2003; Weinstein and Lawson, 2002). Complete loss of Notch signaling, as occurs in mutants for mindbomb (mib), an E3 ubiquitin ligase involved in Notch activation, results in deficits of arterial-specific and ectopic vein marker expression within the dorsal aorta (Lawson et al., 2002). Arterial and venous fates are intact in notch3 mutant embryos and in adults, indicating that Notch3 is not involved or that other notch genes compensate for its loss.
In addition to endothelial cell specification, cardiovascular development in mammals and zebrafish involves recruitment of vascular mural cells (vMCs) during a process known as vascular myogenesis (Miano et al., 2006; Owens, 1995; Owens, 1998; Owens et al., 2004; Owens and Wise, 1997; Santoro et al., 2009). vMCs, VSMCs and pericytes initially act as support cells, but subsequently become highly specialized cells that control vasodilation and vessel caliber. During larval development in zebrafish, immature VSMCs are detected adjacent to the dorsal aorta by ultrastructural criteria and marker expression (Miano et al., 2006; Santoro et al., 2009). However, differentiated VSMCs are only apparent after 1 month of development, and definitive VSMCs, defined by dense plaques (hallmarks of a mature actin cytoskeleton), myofilament bundles and a basement membrane, are only apparent at 3 months (Miano et al., 2006; Santoro et al., 2009). Histological and ultrastructural analyses revealed vasodilation of both peripheral arteries and veins of notch3 mutants, indicating that notch3, which is expressed in the walls of both vessel types, has an essential role in limiting vasodilation. Vascular smooth muscle cell contraction and relaxation regulate vessel caliber and local blood pressure in response to demand for oxygenated blood. Differentiated VSMCs display contractile properties, whereas undifferentiated VSMCs are proliferative (Owens, 1995). Pooling of blood and vasodilation in notch3 mutants are consistent with a role for notch3 in promoting the mature, contractile VSMC state to regulate vascular tone. notch3 seems to play an additional role in regulating arterial architecture, because vessels positioned where arteries are typically located had thinner vessel walls, a morphology resembling that of veins rather than the typical thick cell walls of arteries, despite normal arterial venous patterning in vessels of embryos and adults. The absence of obvious patterning defects in embryos is consistent with adult-onset vasculopathy due to defective VSMC maturation or function in notch3 mutants. Mural cells and VSMCs both contribute to the normal vascular response to Vegf in newly forming vessels and during regeneration (Carmeliet and Collen, 1999; Carmeliet and Storkebaum, 2002). We were unable to detect definitive pericytes associated with vessels in bony regions of mutant fin rays (where arteries reside in wild type); thus, impaired pericyte development or recruitment might contribute to impaired vascular integrity. Similarly, VSMC destruction associated with reduced pericytes has been reported in individuals with CADASIL (Kalimo et al., 2002; Ruchoux et al., 2003). Thus, zebrafish notch3 mutant phenotypes show aspects of CADASIL pathology, specifically compromised VSMC and vascular integrity despite the different nature of the mutations in notch3.
Two Notch3 knockout mice have been reported. In contrast to the sub-viable zebrafish mutants, both mouse knockout models are viable and fertile (Arboleda-Velasquez et al., 2008; Domenga et al., 2004; Kitamoto et al., 2005; Krebs et al., 2003). One Notch3 knockout shows deficits in differentiation and maturation of VSMCs of small systemic vessels (Domenga et al., 2004). Similar to zebrafish notch3 mutants, the tail arteries of this Notch3 knockout are enlarged with a thin media reminiscent of veins. Domenga et al. suggested that Notch3 might act through a non-canonical pathway in VSMCs, because expression of classical Notch targets such as Hes genes were normal in Notch3 mutants (Domenga et al., 2004). Instead, they hypothesized that Notch3 acts as a luminal pressure gauge or sensor that modulates the myogenic contractile response via regulation of the actin cytoskeleton (Domenga et al., 2004). In the second mouse knockout, ultrastructural vessel defects were not reported, but transcriptional profiling of purified populations of cerebral VSMCs did show deficits in regulators of muscle contraction, including regulators of cell motility and architecture and modest reductions of some canonical Notch targets, such as Hes1 and Hey1 in isolated VSMCs (Arboleda-Velasquez et al., 2008). Notably, the resting cerebral blood flow (CBF) in both Notch3 mice was normal, but middle cerebral artery occlusion led to an exacerbated stroke phenotype. Specifically, CBF defects and more frequent ischemic lesions without vasoconstriction were observed, thus supporting a role for Notch3 in regulating contractile tone in cerebral vessels (Arboleda-Velasquez et al., 2011; Arboleda-Velasquez et al., 2008; Ayata, 2010; Domenga et al., 2004; Krebs et al., 2003). Similarly, evidence of compromised vascular tone and accumulation of blood in vessels in zebrafish notch3 mutants was prominent in response to mild stress, but difficult to detect otherwise. Thus, notch3 seems to have a conserved function in vascular myogenesis and vessel maturation via a mechanism involving canonical Notch pathway targets. Notably, in both zebrafish and mammals, VSMC differentiation is a Notch3-dependent process that occurs during post-larval (zebrafish) and postnatal (mammals) development. In contrast to mouse knockouts, some of the zebrafish notch3 mutants do not survive to adulthood, perhaps owing to incomplete recovery from early CNS defects.
In summary, we have identified mutations disrupting notch3 that cause oligodendrocyte deficits in embryos and vascular pathology in brain and peripheral tissues of adults, revealing roles for Notch3 in glia and vascular cells. It is thus possible that early glial deficits also contribute to white matter defects in individuals with CADASIL. Although arterial and venous fates are properly specified in embryos and adults, the fin vessels of adults show morphologies that are typical of veins. Moreover, adult vessels are swollen and show evidence of compromised vascular tone, including vasodilation and hemorrhage. Zebrafish notch3 mutants will be valuable for future screens to identify Notch signaling modifiers or risk factors affecting the phenotype, and for studies of the activity of CADASIL mutant alleles and the signaling and cellular mechanisms contributing to vascular and other Notch3-associated pathologies.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The animal work performed in this study was approved by the Institutional Review Boards of Albert Einstein College of Medicine and Stanford University School of Medicine.
Fish strains, mapping and positional cloning
Zebrafish embryos were raised at 28.5°C and staged according to Kimmel et al. (Kimmel et al., 1995). Identification of the st51 mutation has been described (Pogoda et al., 2006). The notch3zm allele was purchased from Znomics.
Wild-type and notch3st51 mutant larvae were sorted based on their mbp expression at 5 dpf. The map position of notch3st51 was refined by scoring SSLP markers from linkage group 3 (LG3) in notchst51 mapping crosses as described (Talbot and Schier, 1999). These mapping studies localized the notch3st51 mutation to a region defined by the markers Z3725 and Z20058, which also contained the notch3 gene (Woods et al., 2005). We sequenced the notch3 gene to find the lesion.
To genotype the notch3 alleles, individual larvae and adults were anesthetized in Tricaine as described and genomic DNA was prepared from adult fin samples or whole embryos and larvae (Westerfield, 1995).
The notch3st51 allele was scored using the following primers to amplify fragments from genomic DNA: forward: 5′-GAGTGCCAGTCGAATCCCTGTC-3′; reverse: 5′-ACACTTGCAGGTGAAACCATTGAGC-3′. The PCR product was digested with RsaI, which cuts the wild-type product but not the mutant.
Two different assays were used to genotype the notch3zm allele. In early experiments, we scored notch3zm by performing two separate PCR assays on each genomic DNA sample. One set of primers (5′-ACTCCGATCCGAAGTGAAGTAG-3′ and 5′-CAGGCAATCACATTAGGATGAA-3′) amplified a 184 bp product from the wild-type allele but no product from the mutant allele. The second set (5′-CTGAAGCCTATAGAGTACGAGCC-3′ and 5′-GTCCGAGCTGCAGAAGGAAATACTG-3′) amplified a product of about 700 bp from the mutant allele but no product from the wild-type allele. In more recent experiments, the following three primers were combined in single PCR reaction to genotype the notch3zm mutation: Common F 5′-GTCCGAGCTGCAGAAGGAAATACTG-3′, ZM R 5′-CTGTGCCTTATTTGAACTAACC-3′ and WT R 5′-GTGGAAACTCGATCCTACTCC-3′. A 283 nt product was amplified from the mutant allele, whereas the wild-type product was 190 nt.
To examine the notch3 mRNA in notch3st51 mutants, RNA was prepared from the body of individual 3-day-old embryos using the Qiagen Rneasy Micro Kit. cDNA was synthesized using the SuperScript II First-Strand System (Invitrogen) with random hexamer primers following the manufacturer’s protocol. The tail of each embryo was used for genotyping as described above. PCR for notch3 was performed on cDNAs with primers flanking the lesion site: forward 5′-GCACTTCAGGTACCAACTGTGA-3′ (across exons 11 and 12) and reverse 5′-AGAGCAAGGTGTGAGCAGTTCT-3′ (from exon 15). The different PCR products from wild-type, heterozygote and mutant cDNAs were run on an agarose gel and then cloned and sequenced. As a control, ef1a was analyzed as described (Monk et al., 2009).
For examination of Notch target expression, total RNA was isolated from wild-type and mutant fins and larvae at the specified stages using TRIZOL according to standard protocols. cDNA was reverse transcribed using SuperScript II reverse transcriptase (Invitrogen) and oligodT primers according to the manufacturer’s instructions. To control for genomic DNA contamination, reverse transcriptase was omitted using the same RNA samples. The following primers were used for qRT-PCR: hey1f 5′-CGATTTCAGCTCGTCGGACA-3′, hey1r 5′-ATGCAGAACCCCATGCCAAG-3′, her9 (Yang et al., 2009), her9f 5′-CCAGCGTTTGCTTCTGCTACAAC-3′, her9r 5′-GCTCATTGCTTTCTGCTCCG-3′, eef1a1l1(ef1α)f 5′-AGCCTGGTATGGTTGTGACCTTCG-3′, eef1a1l1(ef1α)r 5′-CCAAGTTGTTTTCCTTTCCTGCG-3′.
qRT-PCR was performed using an Eppendorf Realplex3 machine according to standard protocols and cycling conditions. For zm genotypes: n=2 biological replicates and 3 technical replicates; for st51 genotypes: n=5 biological and 3 technical replicates. Percent of wild-type expression was calculated using the ΔΔCT method using ef1a as the standard and wild type as the reference. T-test was calculated using Excel (Microsoft).
In situ hybridization
Whole-mount in situ hybridization was performed as described previously (Thisse and Thisse, 1998), except that for analysis of vascular markers and fins BM purple AP (Roche) was used as the substrate for alkaline phosphatase. To generate the notch3 probe, a region of the gene corresponding to bp 14 to 935 of the notch3 cDNA (GenBank accession number AF152001) was cloned into the pCRII-TOPO vector; the plasmid was digested with EcoRV and transcribed with SP6 RNA polymerase. mbp (Lyons et al., 2005), olig2 (Park et al., 2002), sox10 (Dutton et al., 2001), deltaD (Haddon et al., 1998b), flt4 (Lawson et al., 2002), efnb2a (Durbin et al., 1998), deltaC (Smithers et al., 2000), dab2 (Song et al., 2004) and notch1a (Bierkamp and Campos-Ortega, 1993) probes were prepared as previously described. For gfap, an 899 bp fragment of the gene was amplified from 72 hpf larval cDNA using the following primers: gfap1: 5′-GAGATGATGGGGCTAAACGA-3′; gfap2: 5′-TCCAGCAGCTTCCTGTAGGT-3′. The fragment was inserted into the TopoII (Invitrogen) vector; antisense probe was made by cleaving with XbaI and transcribing with SP6 RNA polymerase. For fin vessel analysis using notch3 and deltaC probes, linear templates were amplified from cDNA using the following primers: T7-notch3F 5′-TAATACGACTCACTATAGGGGGTATTTCGAGACGCACGGC-3′, T3-notch3R 5′-CATTAACCCTCACTAAAGGGAATGTGTTGACACCATCGACGC-3′, T3-deltaCF 5′-CATTAACCCTCACTAAAGGGAAGGAGCACCTCAAACACCAGT-3′, T7-deltaCR 5′-TAATACGACTCACTATAGGGCACAACAGCATCCATCATCC-3′.
Immunohistochemistry and cell death assays
Acetylated tubulin [1:1000 mouse α-acetylated alpha tubulin (Sigma, T6793) and 1:100 FITC-conjugated donkey α-mouse antibody (Jackson, 715-095-151)] and HuC/D (Molecular Probes) immunostainings were carried out as described previously (Lyons et al., 2008). Images were acquired on a Zeiss LSM confocal, Zeiss Observer equipped with Apotome, Perkin-Elmer spinning disk confocal or Leica SP2 confocal microscope. After imaging, larvae were genotyped for the notch3 mutation.
Apoptosis was assessed via AO staining as described previously (Lyons et al., 2005).
Tg[fli-EGFP] transgenic larvae at the specified stages were visualized and imaged live or were fixed in 4% PFA and GFP signals were detected using an anti-GFP antibody. Briefly, 51–52 hpf embryos were fixed overnight (O/N) in 4% PFA and then dehydrated in MeOH via 25%/50%/75% MeOH in PBS. Larvae were rehydrated, treated with 10 ng/μl Proteinase K in PBSTri (PBS, 0.5% for Triton X-100) for 30 minutes and postfixed for 20 minutes in 4% PFA. Following washes with PBSTri, the embryos were preincubated for 3 hours in blocking buffer [10% fetal bovine serum (FBS) and 1% DMSO in PBSTri] before incubation with a 1:1000 dilution of chicken anti-GFP antibody (Invitrogen, A10262) in blocking buffer O/N at 4°C. The next day the embryos were washed with PBSTri and preincubated for 3 hours in blocking buffer. Following incubation O/N at 4°C with a 1:300 dilution of Alexa-Fluor-488-conjugated goat anti-chicken antibody (Jackson, 103-545-155) in blocking buffer, immunostained embryos were washed and then mounted in 1% low melting point agarose (Sigma, A9414) in a glass-bottom dish. Dorsal view images were obtained with a Leica SP2 confocal. After imaging, larvae were genotyped for the notch3 mutation.
Anesthetized 2-dpf progeny from clutches of notch3zm/+ intercrosses were embedded in 1% low melting point agarose and 3–4 nl of 1% Fluorescein dextran (Invitrogen, D-1822) was injected into the sinus venosus, essentially as described previously (Weinstein et al., 1995). After injection, the larvae were cut out of the agarose and remounted under anesthesia (Tricaine) in 1% low melting point agarose on a glass bottom dish. The labeled vasculature was imaged in 60–63 hpf larvae using a Leica SP2 confocal microscope. After imaging, larvae were genotyped for the notch3 mutation.
Histology and transmission electron microscopy
Adults were anesthetized and the brains were dissected and fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde and embedded in paraffin. 10-μm sagittal sections were cut on a microtome, deparaffinized, and stained with H&E.
Fins from wild-type and notch3 mutants were clipped according to standard protocols and fixed with 2.5% glutaraldehyde, 2% paraformaldehyde in 0.1 M sodium cacodylate buffer, postfixed with 1% osmium tetroxide followed by 2% uranyl acetate, dehydrated through a graded series of ethanol and embedded in LX112 resin (LADD Research Industries, Burlington, VT). Ultrathin sections (80 nM) were cut on a Reichert Ultracut UCT, stained with uranyl acetate followed by lead citrate and viewed on a JEOL 1200EX transmission electron microscope at 80 kv.
Toluidine-blue-stained sections (1 μM) were coated with permount solution, coverslipped, and images were acquired with an Axioskop2 microscope and Axiocam CCD camera (Zeiss). Images were processed in ImageJ, Adobe Photoshop and Adobe Illustrator.
Quantification of vessel defects
The circumference of vessels within the bony regions of the fin rays (i.e. where arteries are positioned in wild type) was traced and the diameter was determined using ImageJ software. The distance between bony segments was measured using ImageJ (as depicted in Fig. 5A). The ratio of the artery/vessel diameter to length between the bone segments was calculated and plotted using Excel (Microsoft). ANOVA analysis was performed using the calculator at http://www.physics.csbsju.edu/stats/anova_pnp_NGROUP_form.html.
The authors thank members of the Marlow and Talbot labs for helpful discussions, Xin Li and Drs Lei Fang and Andreas Jenny for critical evaluation of the manuscript, Spartak Kalinin, Clinton Depaolo and Tuky Reyes for fish care, Alya Raphael for providing the gfap clone, William Joo for assistance with early analysis of the notch3zm mutation, and the Einstein Analytical Imaging Facility of Albert Einstein College of Medicine for histology and TEM services and confocal support.
This work was supported by grants to F.L.M. from the National Institutes of Health (NIH; R01GM089979), and to W.S.T. from NIH (R01 NS050223) and the NMSS (RG-4756-A-3). S.M. was supported by a fellowship from Telethon Italy (GFP03011). N.S. was supported by a predoctoral fellowship from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute (HHMI).
The authors declare that they do not have any competing or financial interests.
Conceived and designed the experiments: A.Z., S.M., N.S., W.S.T. and F.L.M. Performed the experiments: A.Z., S.M. and N.S. Analyzed the data: A.Z., S.M., N.S., W.S.T. and F.L.M. All authors discussed the data and the manuscript. A.Z., W.S.T. and F.L.M. wrote the manuscript.
Supplementary material for this article is available at http://dmm.biologists.org/lookup/suppl/doi:10.1242/dmm.012005/-/DC1
- Received February 3, 2013.
- Accepted May 22, 2013.
- © 2013. Published by The Company of Biologists Ltd
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution and reproduction in any medium provided that the original work is properly attributed.